Hurdle Rate and Preferred Return in Private Equity Funds
A hurdle rate, also called a preferred return, is the minimum annual return investors (LPs) must receive on their capital before the fund manager (GP) earns carried interest. In private equity the two terms mean the same thing. The standard rate in buyout funds is still 8% a year, compounded: Proskauer's June 2026 survey found it in 89% of North American buyout funds. But the headline rate is only part of the story. How the preferred return is calculated, when it starts accruing and what capital it applies to can move millions between LPs and the GP.
This guide explains how the hurdle is defined and calculated, what is standard by strategy, and what to negotiate. For how the hurdle fits into the full payout order, including the GP catch-up and clawback, see our guide to European vs American distribution waterfalls.
1. What the Hurdle Is, and What It Is Not
- Same thing, two names: fund documents use "hurdle rate" and "preferred return" interchangeably.
- A priority, not a promise: the preferred return is a place in the payout order, not a guaranteed payment. If the fund does not earn it, LPs get whatever is available and the GP gets no carry.
- Soft vs hard: most funds use a soft hurdle with a catch-up, so once LPs clear the hurdle the GP catches up to its full 20% of profits. A hard hurdle has no catch-up, so the GP only earns carry on profits above the hurdle. The waterfall guide shows both with numbers.
- Why it exists: it compensates LPs for locking up money for years and stops the GP earning carry on returns LPs could have made in safer assets.
Why 8%?
There is no documented origin. Law firms and consultants trace it to the late 1970s and 1980s, when 8% was close to the yield on government bonds of similar length to a private equity fund. The rate has stayed fixed ever since, through near-zero interest rates and through 5% rates. An older academic study of funds raised from 1993 to 2006 found 8% was the most common hurdle, used by about three-quarters of buyout funds that had one (Metrick and Yasuda, 2010).
Hurdles outside private equity
- Hedge funds usually rely on a high-water mark: the manager only earns performance fees on gains above the fund's previous peak value. Some also use a hurdle, a minimum return each period.
- Semi-liquid real estate funds can combine both. Blackstone's BREIT, for example, charges 12.5% of total return, subject to a 5% annual hurdle and a high-water mark.
2. How the Preferred Return Is Calculated
Compounding vs simple
- Simple: preferred return = capital × rate × years.
- Compounded annually: preferred return = capital × [(1 + rate)years − 1]. This works like an IRR test.
- The ILPA model uses "compounded annually and calculated daily."
Goodwin's January 2024 data found 50% of funds use a compounding rate, 38% an IRR test and 12% a percentage of capital drawn or committed (Goodwin). Debt funds are the most likely to compound (74%).
When it starts accruing
The preferred return normally runs from the date LPs contribute capital. But most funds now use subscription lines, borrowing to buy assets and calling LP capital weeks or months later. ILPA's 2021 survey found 98% of funds can use one. That delays the start of accrual, shrinks the preferred return and brings the GP's carry forward. ILPA's model agreement says the preferred return should run from the date the credit line is drawn, but law firms report this is rarely agreed in practice.
What capital it applies to
- All contributed capital, including fees and expenses: the ILPA model and common in whole-fund (European) waterfalls.
- Invested capital only, or only fees linked to a deal: more common in deal-by-deal (American) waterfalls. Paul Weiss's 2024 survey of large funds found 66% of deal-by-deal funds return only allocable expenses before carry.
- Cumulative cash-flow method: most managers now accrue the preferred return only while total contributions exceed total distributions. This stops a small late capital call from restarting the clock on a fund that has already returned large profits.
Multiple-based hurdles and fair value tests
- Multiple (MOIC) hurdles: carry starts once LPs have received, say, 1.2x to 1.3x their money. Common in venture and continuation funds. They do not penalise slow exits, so they give LPs no protection for time.
- Fair value tests: carry is allowed once the fund's value exceeds a threshold. 10% of large buyout funds use one instead of a preferred return (Paul Weiss, April 2024). They are much more GP-friendly.
- Tiered carry: some funds raise carry from 20% to 25% or 30% above higher return levels.
Cumulative vs non-cumulative (real estate)
Real estate syndications usually pay the preferred return from rental income during the hold. With a cumulative preferred return, any shortfall is carried forward and must be paid before the sponsor takes its share of profits (the promote). With a non-cumulative one, shortfalls are lost.
3. Worked Examples
All examples use an 8% preferred return, 20% carry, single exits and simplified timing. They are illustrations, not market quotes.
Example A: Compounding vs simple ($10 million)
- Exit after 5 years: simple $10M × 8% × 5 = $4.00M. Compounded $10M × (1.085 − 1) = $4.69M. Difference $0.69M.
- Exit after 7 years: simple $5.60M. Compounded $10M × (1.087 − 1) = $7.14M. Difference $1.54M.
The gap grows with the holding period, which matters because private equity holding periods have lengthened.
Example B: A subscription line delays the capital call by 9 months
The fund buys an asset with borrowed money at the start and calls $10 million from LPs 9 months later. The asset is sold 5 years after the purchase.
- Accrual from the date the line is drawn (ILPA): 5 years, so $10M × (1.085 − 1) = $4.69M.
- Accrual from the capital call (common practice): 4.25 years, so $10M × (1.084.25 − 1) = $3.87M.
- Difference: about $0.82M less preferred return for LPs, from the timing alone. For more on how credit lines affect calls, see capital calls explained.
Example C: Including fees in the base ($100 million fund)
LPs contribute $100 million: $85 million invested and $15 million of fees and expenses. One exit after 6 years.
- Preferred return on all $100M: $100M × (1.086 − 1) = $58.69M. Total hurdle with capital: $158.69M.
- Preferred return on $85M only, with fees still returned: $49.88M. Total hurdle: $149.88M.
- Preferred return on $85M, fees not returned before carry: total hurdle $134.88M.
Excluding fees from the base lowers the hurdle by about $8.8 million; also skipping the return of fees lowers it by $23.8 million. In practice fees are paid gradually, so treat these as upper limits.
Example D: How the rate changes GP carry
A $100 million fund makes one distribution after 6 years: $150 million (1.5x, about a 7% IRR) or $200 million (2.0x, about a 12% IRR). The preferred return owed after 6 years is $41.9M at 6%, $50.1M at 7%, $58.7M at 8% and $77.2M at 10%.
- At 1.5x with a 100% catch-up: the GP earns $8.1M with a 6% hurdle, but nothing at 7%, 8% or 10%.
- At 2.0x with a 100% catch-up: the GP earns the full $20M at every rate from 6% to 10%.
- At 2.0x with no catch-up (hard hurdle): the GP earns $11.6M at 6%, $10.0M at 7%, $8.3M at 8% and $4.6M at 10%.
So with a catch-up, the rate barely matters for a successful fund; it mainly changes timing. For a mediocre fund, the rate decides whether the GP earns any carry at all. Without a catch-up, every point of hurdle costs the GP real money.
Example E: Real estate, cumulative vs non-cumulative
An LP invests $1 million in a property deal with an 8% simple preferred return ($80,000 a year). Cash paid out is $40,000, $60,000, $100,000 and $120,000 in years 1 to 4, then $1.4 million on sale in year 5. Above the preferred return, profit is split 70% to the LP and 30% to the sponsor.
- Cumulative: the $60,000 shortfall from years 1 and 2 is carried forward and caught up in years 3 and 4 before the sponsor gets anything. Total: LP $1,624,000, sponsor $96,000.
- Non-cumulative: the early shortfalls are lost, and the sponsor takes 30% of the cash above $80,000 in years 3 and 4. Total: LP $1,606,000, sponsor $114,000.
The non-cumulative version moves $18,000 to the sponsor here. The gap grows in deals with weak early cash flow.
4. What Is Standard by Strategy
- Buyout: 8% in 89% of North American buyout funds (Proskauer, June 2026). Among large funds, 79% use 8% and 10% use less (Paul Weiss, 2024). Carlyle's 2025 annual report describes preferred returns of 7% to 9% for most of its carry funds.
- Venture capital: 90% of US venture funds have no preferred return (Proskauer, November 2026). Hurdles are more common in Europe.
- Real estate funds: only 29% use 8%; 7% and 9% are nearly as common, and a 50% catch-up is typical (Goodwin, November 2023).
- Infrastructure: about half use 8%, with 7% and 7.5% next (Goodwin).
- Private credit: mostly 5% to 7%; direct lending typically 5% to 6% (Goodwin; Macfarlanes).
- Business development companies (BDCs): listed credit vehicles test a quarterly hurdle on net investment income, typically 1.5% to 1.75% a quarter (6% to 7% a year). Ares Capital, for example, uses 1.75% a quarter.
Why venture funds skip the hurdle
Venture returns come from a few big winners that can take 10 years or more. A compounding 8% hurdle could block carry for years even in a good fund, and with a full catch-up it would mostly delay carry rather than reduce it. So LPs usually give it up in exchange for other terms.
Why credit funds use lower hurdles
Target returns in private credit are lower, often high single digits, so an 8% hurdle would leave the manager little chance of earning carry. Carry is also lower, often 10% to 15% rather than 20%.
5. Do Higher Interest Rates Change the Hurdle?
With US risk-free rates around 4% to 5% for much of 2023 to 2026, an 8% hurdle gives LPs only a 3 to 4 point premium over cash. Even so:
- Buyout hurdles did not rise. 8% held, and Paul Weiss even saw more large funds below 8% in 2024.
- LP pressure faded. In Dechert's surveys of private equity executives, 53% said LPs had asked for higher hurdles in the year to late 2022, falling to 34% a year later, and 53% said they were discussing lowering the hurdle.
- Private credit moved a little. Macfarlanes reported some managers raising hurdles by 50 to 100 basis points in 2023, while many new direct lending funds stayed at 5%.
- Floating hurdles are rare. A few credit vehicles have tied the hurdle to a base rate such as SOFR, but Macfarlanes found few examples.
For most LPs, the better use of negotiating effort is the calculation terms, not the headline rate.
6. The GP's View
- Why GPs accept hurdles: institutions expect them, and with a full catch-up they cost little in good outcomes.
- Why GPs resist: in a fund returning 6% to 8% a year, the hurdle decides whether the team earns any carry, and delayed carry can push partners to leave. Some large managers have pushed for lower rates or fair value tests.
- Continuation funds: moving assets into a new vehicle can reset the hurdle and lock in carry. ILPA's guidance asks for a "status quo" option for LPs who roll over, with no lower hurdle.
- NAV loans and tax distributions: distributions funded by borrowing, and cash advances to the GP for tax on carry, can help clear the hurdle or pay carry before real exits. Check how your agreement treats them.
7. What to Negotiate
- Rate: 8% for buyout; 6% to 7% for credit, ideally with a floor.
- Compounding: compounded annually, calculated daily, as in the ILPA model.
- Accrual start: from the date the subscription line is drawn, or at least after an agreed period.
- Base: all contributed capital, including fees and expenses.
- Method: the cumulative cash-flow method, with a clear order for applying distributions.
- Hard vs soft hurdle and catch-up: a hard hurdle or a slower catch-up (50% to 80%) gives real protection. See the waterfall guide.
- Fair value tests: resist them, or insist on a high threshold and escrow.
- Real estate: a cumulative preferred return, ideally with arrears that compound.
- Continuation funds: a status quo option with no lower hurdle.
- NAV loans and tax distributions: no carry on borrowing-funded payouts, and tax distributions covered by the clawback.
- Reporting: quarterly reporting of the preferred return accrued, and IRR with and without the credit line.
For emerging managers: a standard 8% compounding preferred return with a 100% catch-up is the easiest path. Offering ILPA-style accrual from the credit line draw costs little if the fund performs and can help you stand out with LPs. See also how VC funds make money and becoming an LP.
8. UK and Europe
European buyout funds mostly use whole-fund waterfalls, so the preferred return is tested on all contributed capital, which makes fee treatment especially important. European venture funds use hurdles more often than US ones, though less than before. Macfarlanes found no significant difference in private credit hurdles between US and European funds. The UK's new carried interest tax regime from April 2026 depends on holding periods, not on hurdle terms.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a hurdle rate in private equity?
The minimum annual return, usually 8% compounded, that LPs must receive on their contributed capital before the GP earns carried interest.
Is a hurdle rate the same as a preferred return?
Yes, in fund documents the terms are used interchangeably. The technical difference is between a hard hurdle, where the GP never earns carry below the threshold, and the usual soft hurdle, where a catch-up lets the GP recover its full share once the hurdle is cleared.
Why is the preferred return usually 8%?
Convention. It is usually traced to the late 1970s and 1980s, when 8% was close to government bond yields over a similar period. There is no definitive documented origin.
Is the preferred return guaranteed?
No. It is a priority in the payout order, not a promise. If the fund underperforms, LPs receive whatever is available and the GP earns no carry.
Is the preferred return compounded?
Usually. About 88% of funds use compounding or an IRR test, according to Goodwin. Simple preferred returns are more common in real estate syndications. On $10 million over 7 years, compounding adds about $1.54 million.
Do VC funds have a hurdle rate?
Rarely in the US. Proskauer found 90% of US venture funds have no preferred return. Hurdles are more common in Europe.
What is a cumulative preferred return?
One where any unpaid preferred return is carried forward and must be paid before the sponsor takes its share of profits. With a non-cumulative preferred return, shortfalls are lost. It matters most in real estate deals that pay out from rental income.
The Bottom Line
The 8% hurdle has barely moved in 40 years, and in buyout it is unlikely to change soon. What changes the outcome is the detail: whether the preferred return compounds, when it starts, what capital it covers, and whether a catch-up follows. LPs who negotiate those terms protect far more value than a fight over the headline rate would win.
Global Capital Network connects LPs, family offices and fund managers through our investor conferences and private investor dinners. Explore our glossary or get in touch to learn more.
This article is general information, not investment, legal or tax advice. The examples are illustrative and simplified; real fund agreements differ. Read your limited partnership agreement and take advice before committing.